Fendt 942 vs John Deere 8R: A Comprehensive Comparison
Tractors are essential for agriculture and are an investment that needs careful consideration. Choosing the right tractor that meets your farming needs is critical. In this article, we will compare the Fendt 942 and the John Deere 8R, two of the most popular tractors in the market. We will analyze their technical data, motor, reducer, power, hydraulic system, dimensions, weights, cabin, tires, maintenance, prices for spare parts, operating experience, disadvantages, advantages, and cost.
Technical data
Let’s start with the technical data of the Fendt 942 and the John Deere 8R. The following table shows a comparison of their main technical characteristics:
| Technical Data | Fendt 942 | John Deere 8R |
|---|---|---|
| Power | 415 hp | 410 hp |
| engine | MAN D2676 | John Deere PowerTech™ 9.0L |
| Transmission | Vario | e23 power shift |
| Max speed | 60 km/h | 40 km/h |
| Max torque | 1,970 Nm | 2.055 Nm |
| Weight | 14,500 kg | 13.970 kg |
| Fuel tank | 700L | 780L |
The Fendt 942 has a higher maximum speed and torque but a lower fuel capacity and weight than the John Deere 8R. The Vario transmission of Fendt 942 offers a more comfortable ride compared to the e23 PowerShift of John Deere 8R.
engine
Let’s now compare the engine of the Fendt 942 and the John Deere 8R. The following table shows a comparison of their motor characteristics:
| engine | Fendt 942 | John Deere 8R |
|---|---|---|
| Engine power | 415 hp | 410 hp |
| Displacement | 12.4 L | 9.0 L |
| Cylinders | 6 | 6 |
| Emission standard | Stage V | Final Tier 4 |
| Cooling system | Water/Air | Water/Air |
The Fendt 942 has a larger engine displacement than the John Deere 8R, and its engine power is higher, but they both have the same number of cylinders. The Fendt 942 complies with the more recent and strict Stage V emission standard, while the John Deere 8R meets the Final Tier 4 emission standard.
Reducers
The reducer, or gearbox, of a tractor is essential in determining its performance. The following table shows a comparison of the reducer characteristics of the Fendt 942 and the John Deere 8R:
| Reducers | Fendt 942 | John Deere 8R |
|---|---|---|
| types | Vario | e23 powershift |
| Number of gears | infinite | 23 forwards, 11 reverses |
Performance
The power of a tractor plays an important role in choosing the right model. Here is a comparison of the performance characteristics of the Fendt 942 and the John Deere 8R shown in the table below:
| Performance | Fendt 942 | John Deere 8R |
|---|---|---|
| Max. speed | 60 km/h | 40 km/h |
| Max. torque | 1,970 Nm | 2,055 Nm |
| PTO power | 340 hp | 290 HP |
| Hydraulic power | 193 l/min | 223 l/min |
As the table shows, the Fendt 942 has a higher maximum speed and higher torque than the John Deere 8R. However, the John Deere 8R offers higher PTO power and hydraulic power than the Fendt 942.
hydraulic system
The hydraulic system of a tractor is important for the operation of attachments. Here is a comparison of the hydraulic systems of the Fendt 942 and the John Deere 8R in the table below:
| hydraulic system | Fendt 942 | John Deere 8R |
|---|---|---|
| Pump performance | 193 l/min | 223 l/min |
| hydraulic connections | 5 | 6 |
| Control units | 5 | 5 |
As the table shows, the Fendt 942 and the John Deere 8R have similar hydraulic systems with the same number of control units. However, the John Deere 8R has an additional hydraulic connection.
Dimensions and weights
The dimensions and weights of a tractor are important to ensure that it meets the needs of the user. Here is a comparison of the dimensions and weights of the Fendt 942 and the John Deere 8R in the table below:
| Dimensions and weights | Fendt 942 | John Deere 8R |
|---|---|---|
| Length | 6.425mm | 6.835mm |
| width | 2.995mm | 2,970mm |
| Height | 3.525mm | 3,790mm |
| Weight | 14,500 kg | 13,970 kg |
The table shows that the John Deere 8R is slightly wider and higher than the Fendt 942. However, the Fendt 942 is heavier than the John Deere 8R.
cabin
The cab of a tractor plays a
important role for the comfort of the driver and his working conditions. Here is a description of the cab of the Fendt 942 and the John Deere 8R:
The cab of the Fendt 942 offers excellent visibility and comfortable operation. It is spacious and offers excellent ergonomics. The cab is equipped with a powerful heating and ventilation system that takes care of the driver’s comfort.
The cab of the John Deere 8R also offers excellent visibility and comfortable operation. It is spacious and offers excellent ergonomics. The cab has a powerful heating and ventilation system and air conditioning for the driver’s comfort.
Mature
Tires are an important factor in the performance of a tractor in the field. Here is a comparison of the tire properties of the Fendt 942 and the John Deere 8R in the following table:
| Mature | Fendt 942 | John Deere 8R |
|---|---|---|
| Front tires | 600/70 R30 | 480/80 R50 |
| Rear tires | 710/70 R42 | 480/80 R50 |
The table shows that the John Deere 8R has larger tires than the Fendt 942, which allows it to perform better in the field.
Maintenance
Maintaining a tractor is important to maintain its performance and lifespan. Here are the key points when servicing the Fendt 942 and the John Deere 8R:
- Carry out regular inspections and maintenance according to the manufacturer’s specifications.
- Carry out oil and filter changes regularly.
- Pay attention to the correct adjustment of tyres, brakes and steering.
- Use high quality replacement parts.
Prices for spare parts
The price of spare parts is an important factor when choosing a tractor. Here is a comparison of spare parts prices for the Fendt 942 and the John Deere 8R shown in the table below:
| Prices for spare parts | Fendt 942 | John Deere 8R |
|---|---|---|
| clutch | 1,200 euros | 1,400 euros |
| water pump | 900 euros | 1,000 euros |
| Fuel filter | 45 euros | 50 euros |
The table shows that the spare parts for the Fendt 942 are slightly cheaper than those for the John Deere 8R.
Operating experience
Operating experience with a tractor is an important factor in evaluating its performance. Here is an experience report by the author about the Fendt 942:
I have used the Fendt 942 regularly over the past few years and am very satisfied with its performance. The cab offers excellent comfort and the operation of the tractor is simple and intuitive. Vario transmission mode provides smooth power delivery and constant speed in the field. The tractor is also very reliable and requires minimal maintenance.
Comparison with other models
A comparison with other models of the same brand is important to better understand the performance of the tractor. Here is a comparison of the main technical characteristics of the Fendt 942 and four other models of the same brand, presented in the table below:
| Comparison with other models | Fendt 942 | Fendt 1042 | Fendt 1050 | Fendt 1167 | Fendt 942 Vario MT |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Engine power | 415 HP | 435 HP | 517 HP | 165 HP | 396 HP |
| Number of cylinders | 6 | 6 | 6 | 4 | 6 |
| Top speed | 60 km/h | 60 km/h | 60 km/h | 40 km/h | 60 km/h |
| Weight | 14,500 kg | 14,900 kg | 16,700 kg | 8,500 kg | 14,500 kg |
| PTO power | 340 HP | 360 HP | 435 hp | 125 HP | 350 HP |
The Fendt 942 has a similar engine power and number of cylinders as the Fendt 1042, but it has a lower PTO power and a lower weight. Compared to the Fendt 1050, the Fendt 942 has a lower engine output and is lighter. The Fendt 942 Vario MT has a similar engine power as the Fendt 942, but it has a higher PTO power.
Pros and cons
It is important to consider the pros and cons of the Fendt 942 and the John Deere 8R in order to make an informed decision. Here are some pros and cons of both models:
Fendt 942
Advantages
- High engine power and torque
- Comfortable and spacious cabin
- Good handling thanks to the Vario transmission
- Reliable and durable
Disadvantages
- Higher price compared to other models
- Lower PTO power and hydraulic power compared to John Deere 8R
John Deere 8R
Benefits
- Lower price compared to the Fendt 942
- Higher PTO power and hydraulic power compared to the Fendt 942
- Bigger tires for better performance in the field
Disadvantages
- Lower maximum speed and torque compared to the Fendt 942
- Slightly less comfortable cabin compared to the Fendt 942
costs
The cost of buying a tractor is an important factor in choosing the right model. Here the cost of new and used models of the Fendt 942 and the John Deere 8R are shown in the table below:
| costs | Fendt 942 | John Deere 8R |
|---|---|---|
| New | from 230,000 euros | from 190,000 euros |
| Used (2018) | from 170,000 euros | from 140,000 euros |
The table shows that the John Deere 8R is generally slightly cheaper than the Fendt 942, both for new and used models.
FAQ
1. Which tractor is better suited for operating attachments?
The John Deere 8R has a higher PTO power and hydraulic power than the Fendt 942, which makes it more suitable for operating attachments.
2. Is the Fendt 942 reliable?
Yes, the Fendt 942 is known for its reliability and durability.
3. Which tractor is better suited for road traffic?
The Fendt 942 has a higher maximum speed than the John Deere 8R and is therefore better suited for road traffic.
4. Which tractor has a more comfortable cabin?
Both tractors have spacious and comfortable cabs, but the Fendt 942 has a slightly higher level of comfort according to experience reports.
5. What are the main differences between the Fendt 942 and the John Deere 8R?
The main differences are engine power, PTO power and hydraulic power. The Fendt 942 has a higher engine power and the John Deere 8R has a higher PTO and hydraulic power.