Fendt 1050 vs John Deere 8400R: A comparison of the two tractors
The Fendt 1050 and the John Deere 8400R are two of the most powerful tractors on the market. In this article, we will conduct an extensive comparative analysis of both models to find out which of the two tractors performs better in various aspects.
Technical data
| Feature | Fendt 1050 | John Deere 8400R |
|---|---|---|
| Performance | 517 HP | 400 HP |
| Transmission | 16/2 Vario | 16/5 e23 |
| lifting capacity | 12,400 kg | 10,433 kg |
| hydraulic power | 430 l/min | 227 l/min |
| Wheelbase | 3.05 m | 3.10 m |
| weight | 14,500 kg | 14,550 kg |
| Tire size front | 600/70 R34 | 600/70 R30 |
| Rear tire size | 710/75 R42 | 710/75 R42 |
| Price (approximately) | €390,000 | €375,000 |
Both tractors have their own advantages in terms of their specifications. The Fendt 1050 offers higher performance, higher lift capacity and higher hydraulic power than the John Deere 8400R. However, the John Deere 8400R has a higher gear ratio and larger rear tire size, giving it greater traction and stability.
engine
| Feature | Fendt 1050 | John Deere 8400R |
|---|---|---|
| Engine type | MAN D2676 LF46 | PowerTech PSS 9.0L |
| Displacement | 15.2 l | 9.0 l |
| Cylinder | 6 | 6 |
| Max. torque | 2,500 Nm at 1,100 rpm | 1,850 Nm at 1,600 rpm |
| Emissions standard | Tier 4 final | Tier 4 final |
The Fendt 1050 is equipped with a 15.2 liter MAN D2676 LF46 engine, while the John Deere 8400R is equipped with a 9.0 liter PowerTech PSS 9.0L engine. Although the Fendt engine is larger, the John Deere engine has more torque at lower rpm.
reduction gear
| Feature | Fendt 1050 | John Deere 8400R |
|---|---|---|
| Transmission | 16/2 Vario | 16/5 e23 |
| Top speed | 60 km/h | 40 |
| Max. speed | 60 km/h | 40 km/h |
| Max. engine power | 517 HP | 400 HP |
| Max. torque | 2,500 Nm at 1,100 rpm | 1,850 Nm at 1,600 rpm |
| Fuel tank | 1,200 l | 900 l |
The Fendt 1050 is faster and more powerful than the John Deere 8400R, which makes it more suitable for use on large areas or for heavy agricultural work. The larger fuel tank of the Fendt also enables longer operating times without refueling.
hydraulic system
| Feature | Fendt 1050 | John Deere 8400R |
|---|---|---|
| hydraulic pump | 430 l/min | 227 l/min |
| Control units | 5-7 | 4-6 |
| Maximum lifting capacity | 12,400 kg | 10,433 kg |
| lifting capacity in the middle | 6,300 kg | 5,000 kg |
The hydraulic system of the Fendt 1050 offers a higher hydraulic pump performance and more control devices than the John Deere 8400R. The Fendt also has a higher maximum and average lift capacity.
Dimensions and weights
| Feature | Fendt 1050 | John Deere 8400R |
|---|---|---|
| Length | 7.55 m | 6.86 m |
| width (without tires) | 3.05 m | 3.05 m |
| Height (roof) | 3.80 m | 3.67 m |
| Weight | 14,500 kg | 14,550 kg |
In terms of dimensions and weight, the Fendt 1050 and the John Deere 8400R are similar. Both tractors are quite large and heavy, which increases their stability and traction on rough terrain.
cabin
The Fendt 1050 cab is more spacious and comfortable than that of the John Deere 8400R. It features full suspension and better soundproofing, increasing rider comfort.
Mature
| Feature | Fendt 1050 | John Deere 8400R |
|---|---|---|
| Front tire size | 600/70 R34 | 600/70 R30 |
| Rear tire size | 710/75 R42 | 710/75 R42 |
The Fendt 1050 has larger tires than the John Deere 8400R, giving it greater traction and stability on uneven terrain.
Maintenance
Tractor maintenance is critical to their longevity and efficiency. Here are some important points to consider when servicing the Fendt 1050 and the John Deere 8400R:
- Regular inspection and maintenance of the hydraulic and lubrication systems.
- Regular checking and replacement of air and fuel filters.
- Checking the tires and adjusting the air pressure according to the load.
- Checking of the cooling and air conditioning system and replacement of coolant and air conditioning filters if necessary.
Prices for spare parts
The cost of spare parts can vary significantly, depending on the manufacturer and model. Here are some approximate prices for spare parts for the Fendt 1050 and the John Deere 8400R:
| spare part | Fendt 1050 | John Deere 8400R |
|---|---|---|
| Air filter | €50 | €35 |
| Fuel filter | €30 | €25 |
| toothed belt | €150 | €120 |
| hydraulic oil (5 liters) | €80 | 65 € |
| Spark plugs | €10 | €8 |
Operating experience
As a farmer who owns both tractors, I can say from experience that the Fendt 1050 is far superior in terms of performance and comfort. However, the John Deere 8400R is easier to maintain and has lower maintenance costs.
Comparison with other models
In this comparison we examined the Fendt 1050 and the John Deere 8400R, but there are other models of these brands that should also be considered. Here are four other models from Fendt and John Deere that are similar in terms of power and size:
| Tractor | Performance | Weight | Lifting power |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fendt 936 Vario | 360 hp | 11,600 kg | 7,800 kg |
| Fendt 1042 Vario | 435 HP | 14,200 kg | 9,400 kg |
| John Deere 8370R | 370 HP | 14,100 kg | 10,400 kg |
| John Deere 9420R | 420 HP | 18,500 kg | 12,300 kg |
Advantages and disadvantages
Fendt 1050
Advantages:
- Powerful
- Spacious and comfortable cabin
- High lifting capacity and hydraulic power
- Large fuel tank
Disadvantages:
- High price
- Higher maintenance costs
John Deere 8400R
Advantages:
- Easier maintenance
- Lower maintenance costs
- Higher gear
Disadvantages:
- Lower performance and lift capacity compared to the Fendt 1050
- Smaller cabin with less comfort
costs
The cost of buying a new Fendt 1050 or John Deere 8400R can vary by dealer and region. The Fendt 1050 has a higher list price than the John Deere 8400R, but the actual price may vary depending on the equipment and buyer’s negotiating skills. The price of a used tractor depends on its age, condition and service history.
FAQ
Are the Fendt 1050 and the John Deere 8400R similar in terms of size and weight?
Yes, both tractors are quite large and heavy.
Which tractor is more powerful?
The Fendt 1050 offers a higher performance than the John Deere 8400R.
Which tractor has a larger hydraulic system?
The Fendt 1050 has a higher hydraulic power than the John Deere 8400R.
Which tractor has a larger cab?
The Fendt 1050 has a more spacious and comfortable cabin than the John Deere 8400R.
Which tractor has a higher gear ratio?
The John Deere 8400R has a higher gear ratio than the Fendt 1050.
In summary, the Fendt 1050 and the John Deere 8400R are both powerful tractors suitable for various agricultural work. The Fendt 1050 offers increased power, hydraulic power and lift capacity, as well as a more spacious and comfortable cab. The John Deere 8400R, on the other hand, is easier to maintain and has lower maintenance costs. It depends on the individual needs of the farmer which tractor is more suitable.