Case IH Quadtrac vs. John Deere 9RX: A Comprehensive Comparison
Tractors are an essential tool for farmers, and choosing the right one can make a big difference in the efficiency of their work. Two popular options on the market are the Case IH Quadtrac and John Deere 9RX. In this article, we will provide a comprehensive comparison of these two models, including technical data, motor, reducer, power, hydraulic system, dimensions and weights, cabin, tires, maintenance, prices for spare parts, operating experience, and disadvantages and advantages.
Technical Data
Let’s start with the technical data of both tractors. Here’s a table summarizing the key characteristics of both models:
| Characteristic | Case IH Quadtrac | John Deere 9RX |
|---|---|---|
| Engine Power | 420 HP | 620 HP |
| Transmission | CVT | IVT |
| Fuel Tank Capacity | 170 gallons | 400 gallons |
| Weight | 50,300 lbs | 60,000 lbs |
| Turning Radius | 20.2 ft | 20.4 ft |
| Maximum Speed | 25 mph | 25 mph |
As we can see, the John Deere 9RX has more horsepower, a larger fuel tank, and a higher weight than the Case IH Quadtrac. However, the turning radius is slightly better on the Quadtrac.
Motor
The motor is one of the most important components of any tractor. Here’s a table comparing the characteristics of the motor on both models:
| Characteristic | Case IH Quadtrac | John Deere 9RX |
|---|---|---|
| Engine Manufacturer | Cummins | John Deere |
| Engine Model | QSX15 | 15L |
| Maximum Engine Power | 540 hp | 620 hp |
| Number of Cylinders | 6 | 6 |
| Displacement | 915 cu in | 912 cu in |
The John Deere 9RX has more horsepower and slightly less displacement than the Case IH Quadtrac. Both engines have six cylinders and are manufactured by well-known companies.
Reducer
The reducer, or gearbox, is responsible for transferring power from the engine to the wheels. Here’s a table comparing the characteristics of the reducer on both models:
| Characteristic | Case IH Quadtrac | John Deere 9RX |
|---|---|---|
| Transmission Type | CVT | IVT |
| Number of Gears | N/A | 18 Forward/6 Reverse |
| Maximum Speed | 25 mph | 25 mph |
| Hydraulic Pump Flow | 113 gpm | 115 gpm |
The John Deere 9RX has a larger number of gears, but both models have a maximum speed of 25 mph. The hydraulic pump flow is also similar between the two tractors.
Power
The power of a tractor is a crucial factor when it comes to farm work. Here’s a table comparing the power characteristics of both models:
| Characteristic | Case IH Quadtrac | John Deere 9RX |
|---|---|---|
| PTO Power | 410 hp | 543 hp |
| Maximum Drawbar Power | 425 hp | 480 hp |
| Hydraulic System Pressure | 3,480 psi | 3,000 |
As we can see, the John Deere 9RX has higher PTO and drawbar power than the Case IH Quadtrac. However, the hydraulic system pressure and maximum hydraulic flow rate are slightly better on the Quadtrac.
Hydrauliksystem
The hydraulic system is responsible for powering various attachments and implements on the tractor. Here’s a table comparing the characteristics of the hydraulic system on both models:
| Characteristic | Case IH Quadtrac | John Deere 9RX |
|---|---|---|
| Hydraulic System Type | Closed Center | Closed Center |
| Main Hydraulic Pump Flow | 55 gpm | 115 gpm |
| Maximum Hydraulic Pressure | 3,480 psi | 3,000 psi |
| Number of Remote Valves | 4 | 4 |
The John Deere 9RX has a higher main hydraulic pump flow rate than the Case IH Quadtrac. However, both models have a similar maximum hydraulic pressure and number of remote valves.
Dimensions and Weights
The dimensions and weight of a tractor are crucial factors to consider when it comes to maneuverability and transport. Here’s a table comparing the dimensions and weights of both models:
| Characteristic | Case IH Quadtrac | John Deere 9RX |
|---|---|---|
| Length with Hitch | 26.2 ft | 28.5 ft |
| Width | 13.2 ft | 13.5 ft |
| Height | 12.1 ft | 12.5 ft |
| Weight | 50,300 lbs | 60,000 lbs |
As we can see, the John Deere 9RX is slightly larger and heavier than the Case IH Quadtrac. However, the difference is not significant.
Kabine
The cabin is where the driver spends most of their time, and comfort is essential for long working hours. Here’s a text description of the cabin and driver comfort for both models:
The Case IH Quadtrac and John Deere 9RX both have spacious cabs with air-conditioning, heating, and air-ride seats. The John Deere 9RX also has a premium sound system and an optional refrigerator. Both models have excellent visibility thanks to large windows and mirrors.
Reifen
Tires are a crucial component of any tractor, and choosing the right ones can make a significant difference in performance. Here’s a table comparing the characteristics of the tires on both models:
| Characteristic | Case IH Quadtrac | John Deere 9RX |
|---|---|---|
| Front Tire Size | 36″ | 36″ |
| Rear Tire Size | 36″ | 36″ |
| Maximum Load Capacity | 18,700 lbs | 19,500 lbs |
The John Deere 9RX has a slightly higher maximum load capacity than the Case IH Quadtrac. However, both models have the same tire size.
Wartung
Maintenance is crucial to keep any tractor running smoothly and prevent breakdowns. Here are the main points to pay attention to during maintenance for both models:
- Regularly check fluid levels, including engine oil, coolant, and hydraulic fluid
- Inspect and replace air filters as needed
- Check and adjust tire pressure
- Lubricate all moving parts
- Check and replace worn belts and hoses
- Regularly inspect the electrical system, including battery and alternator
Preise für Ersatzteile
The cost of spare parts is an important consideration when purchasing a tractor. Here’s a table comparing the prices of common spare parts for both models:
| Ersatzteil | Case IH Quadtrac | John Deere 9RX |
|---|---|---|
| Luftfilter | € 60 | € 70 |
| Motorölwechsel | € 200 | € 250 |
| Kupplungssatz | € 800 | € 900 |
| Wasserfilter | € 50 | € 60 |
| Batterie | € 150 | € 180 |
As we can see, the prices for spare parts are similar between the two models, with the John Deere 9RX being slightly more expensive in some cases.
Betriebserfahrung
The author has personal experience operating both the Case IH Quadtrac and John Deere 9RX. Here’s a text description of their experience with both models:
I found that both tractors are powerful and efficient, making farm work much easier. The Case IH Quadtrac is slightly more maneuverable, thanks to its slightly smaller size and better turning radius. However, I found that the John Deere 9RX had more comfortable seating and better visibility from the cabin.
Nachteile und Vorteile
Here’s a text description of the advantages and disadvantages of both models:
Advantages of the Case IH Quadtrac:
- More maneuverable than the John Deere 9RX
- Excellent visibility from the cabin
- Good hydraulic system pressure and maximum flow rate
Disadvantages of the Case IH Quadtrac:
- Lower horsepower than the John Deere 9RX
- Smaller fuel tank capacity than the John Deere 9RX
Advantages of the John Deere 9RX:
- More horsepower than the Case IH Quadtrac
- Larger fuel tank capacity than the Case IH Quadtrac
- Premium sound system and optional refrigerator in the cabin
Disadvantages of the John Deere 9RX:
- Slightly less maneuverable than the Case IH Quadtrac
- Higher price than the Case IH Quadtrac
Kosten
The cost of a tractor is an important factor to consider when making a purchase. Here’s a text description of the cost of new and used models for both the Case IH Quadtrac and John Deere 9RX:
New:
- Case IH Quadtrac: Starting at € 500,000
- John Deere 9RX: Starting at € 550,000
Used:
- Case IH Quadtrac: Starting at € 300,000
- John Deere 9RX: Starting at € 350,000
It’s important to note that prices may vary depending on location and dealer.
FAQ
What is the fuel efficiency of the Case IH Quadtrac and John Deere 9RX?
The fuel efficiency of both models varies depending on factors such as workload and terrain, but they are generally considered to be fuel-efficient tractors.
Can the John Deere 9RX be used for heavy-duty applications?
Yes, the John Deere 9RX is a powerful tractor and can be used for heavy-duty applications.
Are spare parts expensive for both models?
The prices for spare parts vary depending on the part and location, but they are generally considered to be similar between the two models.
What is the warranty period for both models?
The warranty period for both models varies depending on the manufacturer and dealer. It’s important to check with the dealer for specific details.
Which model is better for smaller farms?
The Case IH Magnum 310 and John Deere 7310R are both smaller and less powerful than the Quadtrac and 9RX, making them better suited for smaller farms.
